← gabephilipson.com
LIVE · VOL. I, NO. 33

The Intangibles Index

—

A wins predictor for the analytically overconfident. Because Wins Above Replacement cannot measure what you lose when you trade or give away your clubhouse.

Subject: 2026 New York Mets · Live Readout
Record
74 – 88
Final Streak
L 1
Payroll
$381M
PECOTA Projection
89wins
Final Win Total
74wins
PECOTABaseball Prospectus's preseason win forecast (Nate Silver's model)
Final Win Totalall 162 played, nothing left to extrapolate
“
—
—
Preset Archetypes — click to load
1 / 4
Output · The Prediction
Intangibles-Adjusted
72
full model · quant + the α correction
Quant-Only
89
if intangibles = 0 · the preseason spreadsheet
2026 Mets Final Record
74
through 162 games · 74-88
The spreadsheet misses by 15 wins. With the intangibles (α) correction, the full model misses by just 2.
Cost Efficiency Audit · What each win actually costs
Cost Per Win
$5.15M
payroll ÷ wins
Historical Percentile
BOTTOM 1% Historically inefficient
Efficiency Spectrum
2026 METS LEAGUE AVG 2002 A'S
Tune The Model

Change the prediction above by adjusting the model below, including the intangibles. Move the quantifiable WAR inputs on the left, or the harder-to-measure clubhouse factors on the right, and watch the forecast shift.

The Quant Side

β · fWAR

What the projection systems see. Numbers have opinions about these.

fWAR · Fangraphs Wins Above Replacement Fangraphs' version of the all-in-one stat that estimates how many wins a player adds versus a freely-available "replacement" player (think Triple-A call-up). A good regular sits around 2.0. An All-Star clears 4.0. An MVP season goes 7+. Sum every player on the roster and you have the team's total quantifiable value.

The Intangibles Side

α · Intangibles

What the projection systems don't see. What David Stearns gave away.

August 3, 2026 · The Fire Sale seven trades, all prospects back
Freddy Peralta → TB
Clay Holmes → CHC
Tyrone Taylor → CHC
A.J. Minter → MIN
Brooks Raley → PHI
Luke Weaver → PIT
Huascar Brazobán → CWS
Ben Rortvedt → LAD
Eight players out in seven trades, the bullpen emptied to the walls, and every one of them returned prospects. The only arm coming back with big league service has thrown two games. Stearns called it a tremendous amount of talent, which is what you say when none of it can help you this year.
The Intangibles Ledger — 2026 Moves, Projected vs Final Snapshot as of October 16, 2026 · Season complete

Given Away α · proj → final

  • Brandon Nimmo CF · TEX
    .260, 14 HR, and Texas missed the West by a game
    proj 2.9 final 1.7 −1.2 ▼
  • Edwin Díaz CL · LAD
    8.68 ERA, lost the ninth, then saved two NLDS games
    proj 1.3 final 0.1 −1.2 ▼
  • Pete Alonso 1B · BAL
    43 HR, 113 RBI, led the AL and took a Citi Field curtain call
    proj 3.6 final 5.0 +1.4 ▲
  • Starling Marte OF · FA
    released by Kansas City in August, a free agent now
    proj 0.4 final −0.5 −0.9 ▼
  • Jeff McNeil 2B · ATH
    .264, 9 HR, 144 games of almost exactly nothing
    proj 2.6 final 0.1 −2.5 ▼
Given Away proj 10.8 final 6.4 −4.4 ▼

Acquired β · proj → final

  • Luis Robert Jr. CF · BAL
    waived in August, claimed by Baltimore, hurt three games laterinj
    proj 2.1 final 0.5 −1.6 ▼
  • Freddy Peralta SP · TB
    4.99 ERA as a Met, Pitcher of the Month as a Ray
    proj 2.5 final 1.9 −0.6 ▼
  • Bo Bichette SS
    .260, 18 HR, 160 games, the one who stayed upright
    proj 3.8 final 1.9 −1.9 ▼
  • Devin Williams CL
    shoulder IL in August, returned to find Senga closing
    proj 1.1 final 0.8 −0.3 ▼
  • Marcus Semien 2B
    .215, 15 HR, finished the year below replacement
    proj 2.8 final −0.5 −3.3 ▼
  • Jorge Polanco DH
    .148 in 37 games, ankle IL in August, season overinj
    proj 2.1 final −1.4 −3.5 ▼
Acquired proj 14.4 final 3.2 −11.2 ▼
The Trade: Projected vs Realized acquired minus given away · fWAR
Projected swing +3.6
Realized −3.2
Through 162 games the Mets finished 74-88, last in the National League East and twenty games back. There is no pace left to project. The winter's moves projected to add 3.6 wins of value over what walked out the door. They finished 3.2 wins underwater, a 6.8-win miss. Pete Alonso, allowed to walk in the defense-first winter, led the American League with 43 home runs and put up 5.0 fWAR in Baltimore, more than the six acquisitions combined. Freddy Peralta was flipped to Tampa Bay and became the American League's September Pitcher of the Month. Luis Robert Jr. was waived and finished the year on Baltimore's injured list. David Stearns says he will retire the phrase "run prevention," and Andy Green got a three-year deal without a search. Add the intangibles (clubhouse, crowd, fan favorite equity) and the swing is uglier still.
E(W) = Wr + β · fWAR + α + ε
Wr · Replacement Floor

A team of freely available talent wins ≈ 48 games.

β · fWAR

The quantifiable part. Your roster's projected Fangraphs Wins Above Replacement.

α · Intangibles

Everything the spreadsheet can't see. Chemistry, leadership, vibes.

ε · Error

Luck. BABIP. The ump. The ball.